The building has been extensively renovated, adding the kitchen, the refrigerator and cooling areas, plus an additional rest room. Also, the interior was painted and redecorated and an outside dining patio was added.
Today, Madison's third city hall is the popular Main Street Cafe. Opened in December 2000, the cafe features the two previous jail cells as private dining rooms. Owners Tony and Cindy Sensenberger leased the building in 2000 from the city of Madison. As of 2018, John and Tammy Hall have partnered with the Sensenbergers and oversee the daily management of the restaurant and continue growing the business.